As founder and president of HOME Agency, I help mission-driven organizations clarify how they talk about their work, build visibility, and connect marketing to growth and fundraising.
When we launched an award last year offering $100,000 in pro bono strategy, creative, and marketing support, we received applications from 87 nonprofits, spanning issue areas including arts and culture, health and wellness, youth and education, housing, and community development. Despite their different missions, many described some version of the same frustration: “No one knows we exist.”
Is it an awareness problem or a clarity problem?
That sounds like an awareness problem. Often, however, it is a clarity problem. People outside the organization may not immediately understand what you do, why it matters, or how they can learn more or support the work.
The applicants identified a remarkably consistent set of needs: visibility and awareness (87%), website redesign (70%), digital campaign strategy (70%), SEO (65%), social content strategy (63%), and updated branding (56%). All these challenges stem from a lack of clarity. A new website won’t solve unclear messaging. More social content won’t help if every post tells a different story. SEO can help people find you, but it can’t help them understand your mission.
Here’s what you can do to create a clearer nonprofit marketing strategy:
1. Start with five people and one question
There is a simple diagnostic any nonprofit can run: Ask five people who experience your organization in different ways—perhaps a staff member, board member, volunteer, donor, and program participant—the same question:“What does this organization do, and why does it matter?”
Compare their answers. You’re not looking for identical language. You’re looking for a common story. Do they describe the same fundamental work? Do they agree about whom you serve? Do they give a similar reason for why the work matters? Getting your existing community aligned around a clear, repeatable story is the first step.
Then look at your homepage, latest fundraising email, press releases, and social posts. If someone encountered only one of them, would they understand what your organization does and why it matters?
The language can change. The story should not.
2. Make your story easy to repeat
Start with one plain-language sentence that explains what your nonprofit does and why it matters. It needs to say just enough, clearly enough, to help people understand enough to want to know more. Then test it with someone outside your field. If they need you to explain the explanation, keep working on it.
Once you have it, give it to your staff and board. A board member introducing your organization to a colleague, a volunteer talking to a friend, and a donor describing why they support you are all part of your communications infrastructure. Make it easier for them to tell your story.
3. Tell each audience the story in their language
Clarity and consistency doesn’t mean saying exactly the same thing to everyone.
Imagine a youth arts organization whose central idea is that access to meaningful arts experiences helps young people build confidence and connection.
To a parent, that might be: “Give your child a place to create, build confidence, and belong.”
To a donor: “Your support gives more young people access to arts experiences that build confidence and connection.”
To a community partner: “Together, we can make high-quality arts experiences accessible to more young people in our community.”
The fundamental story remains constant; the emphasis and call to action can change with the audience. Before creating an email, webpage, social post, or campaign, identify the primary audience. Consider what that person already knows, what they care about, what you want them to understand, and what you want them to do next.
4. Communicate with supporters beyond ‘the ask’
Once you’ve established a clear, consistent story, you need to build relationships with people who care about your mission.
Review your last five communications to supporters. How many asked for a donation, registration, attendance, volunteer commitment, or another action? How many simply helped someone understand or feel connected to the work?
Share a moment from a program. Show what a donor helped make possible. Explain an issue you’re seeing in the community. Introduce an individual doing the work.
Make sure you’re ready to be found
Some nonprofits do need a better website, stronger SEO, more effective social media, advertising, or a larger communications budget. But the return on those investments are much higher when they’re grounded in a clear, consistent story.
Before asking, “How do we get more people to see us?” ask: “When people do see us, do they understand us?”
Many nonprofits have already built the hardest, most important assets: meaningful work, compelling stories, committed people, and real impact. The first step toward greater visibility may not be reaching more people. It may be making it easier for the people you already reach to understand, remember, and share why your work matters.
Candid insights publication guidelines
