Why SIM-binding mandate is concern for consumers, MSMEs, and cybersecurity, a new study decodes | Mint
Why SIM-binding mandate is concern for consumers, MSMEs, and cybersecurity, a new study decodes
The Esya Centre study finds that India’s proposed SIM-binding mandate could disrupt consumers and MSMEs, increase business costs and offer limited cybersecurity benefits, leaving phishing, malware and other cyber fraud risks largely unaddressed.
The Indian government’s plan to introduce a new provision requiring both physical and digital SIM cards to be linked to messaging apps has sparked opposition from businesses and consumers, as it will not make any <a href="https://bitcomme.com/investors-back-mach9-with-a-significant-series-a-to-bring-ai-to-civil-engineering/” title=”Investors back Mach9 with a significant Series A to bring AI to civil engineering”>significant difference to cybersecurity, a new study by the think tank Esya Centre has concluded.
The report, titled “Rethinking India’s SIM Binding Mandate: An Empirical Assessment“, investigates the possible implications of the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) order on users, businesses, and digital security.
The study, which polled 2,033 consumers in 18 cities and 353 businesses in 17 cities, identified several problems, including communication disruption, increased operational costs, and the effectiveness of SIM binding in combating cyber fraud. It says that limitations on access to messaging could affect legitimate users while leaving more significant cybercrime techniques, such as phishing, credential theft, malware, and session hijacking, essentially unchecked.
SIM-binding mandates could disrupt consumers, especially during travel
In November 2025, the DoT announced theSIM-binding directive to tie internet-based messaging apps to active SIMs. It also originally required a logout of Web sessions after every 6 hours of inactivity. However, the government later revised the logout requirement to a risk-based approach.
The study by the Esya Centre says that the need might pose problems to international travellers who rely on local phone numbers, Wi-Fi, or alternative data connections. Of the surveyed international travellers, 67.1% used alternative modes of connectivity, compared with 33% who used Indian SIMs with international roaming services.
98.88% of the consumers surveyed found losing messaging access because of an inactiveSIM card to be an inconvenience, the report revealed. Meanwhile, 98% said they were concerned about not being able to use the Internet during emergencies. Some 97.7% of companion-device users also indicated that forced logouts would interfere with their use of the device.
Also Read|Removed your SIM card? WhatsApp and Telegram users may face access issues
MSMEs could face higher costs and operational disruptions
The directive may also affect companies that rely on messaging systems for business communications, employee coordination, and operations.
The Esya Centre discovered 92% of the businesses surveyed had companion-device access, and 86% had the same business number across their devices. 78% thought that restricting access to the phone would be moderately or extremely disruptive, and 83.5% said they would expect operational delays and errors.
82% of the businesses surveyed said they would be interrupted by forced logouts. The financial impact can be particularly severe for MSMEs, with 76.3% anticipating high additional costs.
The report also revealed that 60.6% of businesses were looking for more costs to be associated with the workplace, 58.6% of businesses were looking for more spending on devices and equipment and 55% of businesses were looking for more staffing.
Study questions on SIM binding’s effectiveness against cyber fraud
The report also raises doubts about how wellSIM binding can prevent modern-day cyber fraud, as well as about consumer and business issues.
87.2% of businesses surveyed were worried about SIM fraud, yet 81% were not convinced that SIM binding would be a worthwhile security measure. Similarly, 59% of consumers doubted that the requirement would make messaging platforms safer.
In the study, the researchers conclude that phishing, social engineering, stolen credentials and malware are all being used alongside SIM-related vulnerabilities as additional tools for cybercriminals.
It also cautions that the restrictions may drive users to other solutions. Approximately 41% of consumers surveyed indicated they would get a second SIM card, and 30.3% said they would buy another device.
Also Read|Vivo Y32 5G unveiled with 8,000mAh battery, 44W charging and IP69 rating
What does the Esya Centre recommend?
Instead of relying primarily on messaging access restrictions, the report recommends a targeted, risk-based approach to fraud prevention. It recommends enhanced Know Your Customer (KYC) procedures, stricter measures to prevent the issuance of SIM cards, improved fraud-detection measures, and action against mule-account networks.
The think tank also suggests that detailed analysis be carried out prior to implementing substantial changes to the regulations. These assessments should encompass price advantages for consumers, business and communication reliability, as well as cybersecurity advantages.
The report concludes that India’s fraud-prevention strategy should focus on addressing the underlying methods used by cybercriminals while ensuring that legitimate consumers and businesses can continue accessing digital communication services without unnecessary disruptions.
About the Author
Pragya is a Technology reporter with over four years of experience in digital media and content writing. She holds a Master’s degree in Journalism and has covered a wide range of stories spanning space, smartphones, gadgets, artificial intelligence, emerging technologies and the ways technology is transforming everyday life. She focuses on breaking down complex technology and science developments into clear, engaging, and reader-friendly stories, with a keen interest in emerging trends and their real-world impact. Before joining her current newsroom, Pragya worked with News9Live, where she covered the technology beat extensively, reporting on smartphones, consumer technology, AI, space and science, while also contributing to video and visual content. Her experience includes breaking news, explainers, SEO-driven stories, product coverage, interviews, unboxing videos and live event reporting. She has also covered major technology and AI events, giving her experience in both newsroom and on-ground reporting. Beyond journalism, Pragya is an avid gamer and a passionate reader of fiction. She enjoys exploring immersive worlds through games and books, with a particular interest in stories that offer new perspectives, ideas, and experiences.
Catch all theTechnology Newsand Updates on Live Mint. Download TheMint News Appto get DailyMarket Updates& LiveBusiness News.
HomeTechnologyWhy SIM-binding mandate is concern for consumers, MSMEs, and cybersecurity, a new study decodes
More
