Three high-yield stocks spanning two asset classes can quietly build a passive income stream that outpaces most savings accounts, but the yields that make them attractive also carry tradeoffs worth understanding before you buy.
A dividend hits your brokerage account regardless of market direction. That is the appeal of an income-first portfolio: the cash keeps arriving whether the market is green, red, or sideways. Rate cuts, election noise, and macro headlines change the mood, but a monthly check from a REIT or a quarterly one from a BDC lands on schedule regardless.
Here is what a $1,000 stake in each of these three high-yield names would generate in annual income on a total $3,000 investment. The roster mixes two business development companies with one experiential net-lease REIT, and the blended cash flow clears the $200 mark. All yields quoted are forward yields, calculated from each name’s current regular declared distribution. Coverage is measured with the metric appropriate to each structure: net investment income for the BDCs, FFO and AFFO for the REIT.
Main Street Capital
- Stock #3: Main Street Capital (NYSE:MAIN | MAIN Price Prediction)
- Forward Yield: 5.64%
- Shares for $1,000: 17.7462
- Annual Passive Income: ~$56.43
Main Street is an internally managed BDC focused on lower middle market and private loan investments to U.S. companies, with a market cap of roughly $5.27 billion. The yield sits where it does because BDCs pass through substantially all taxable income to shareholders, and MAIN layers a supplemental payment on top of its monthly regular dividend (we rounded up seven of our favorite every-30-days payers in a free report you can grab here). The forward yield here reflects the regular monthly rate of $0.265 only; the 20th consecutive quarterly supplemental of $0.30 is real cash but excluded from the convention.
Coverage is solid. Second-quarter DNII before taxes was $1.08 per share against roughly $0.795 in quarterly regular distributions, and non-accruals sit at just 1.1% of the portfolio at fair value. Q4 regular monthly dividends were declared at $0.27, the twelfth increase since Q4 2021.
EPR Properties
- Stock #2: EPR Properties (NYSE:EPR)
- Forward Yield: 6.39%
- Shares for $1,000: 17.1674
- Annual Passive Income: ~$63.86
EPR is an experiential net-lease REIT owning theatres, attractions including Six Flags parks, Topgolf eat-and-play venues, fitness, ski, experiential lodging, gaming, and cultural properties. The ultra-high-yield reflects the REIT distribution requirement to pay out 90% of taxable income, plus a lingering market discount tied to theatre exposure, even as management has actively diversified away from it.
Dividend safety looks healthy on the appropriate metric. Q2 2026 AFFO came in at $1.43 per share, an AFFO payout ratio of 65%, and 2026 FFOAA guidance was raised to $5.41 to $5.57 per share, comfortably above the $3.72 annualized dividend. Portfolio rent coverage is 2.0 times and the portfolio is 99% leased or operated. CFO Mark Peterson stated that “our common dividend continues to be very well covered.”
Ares Capital
- Stock #1: Ares Capital (NASDAQ:ARCC)
- Forward Yield: 9.90%
- Shares for $1,000: 51.5730
- Annual Passive Income: ~$99.02
Ares Capital is the largest publicly traded BDC, externally managed by Ares Management, providing primarily first-lien senior secured loans to U.S. middle-market companies across a $29.35 billion portfolio spanning 619 companies, with 71% floating rate exposure. The near-double-digit yield reflects the same BDC pass-through structure MAIN uses, amplified by a floating-rate book earning a weighted average yield on debt at amortized cost of 10.3%.
Coverage is tighter here and worth flagging. Q2 core earnings of $0.47 per share came in one penny below the $0.48 quarterly dividend, but management noted core earnings exceeded the regular dividend over the last 12 months, backed by approximately $988 million, or $1.38 per share, of estimated taxable income spillover and 17 consecutive years of stable or increasing regular quarterly dividends. Non-accruals ticked up to 2.4% at cost from 2.1%, still below the BDC historical average of roughly 4%.
Income Summary
| Name | Forward Yield | Annual Dividend Income |
|---|---|---|
| Main Street Capital | 5.64% | $56.43 |
| EPR Properties | 6.39% | $63.86 |
| Ares Capital | 9.90% | $99.02 |
| Total | 7.31% | $219.31 |
Combined, these three positions generate $219.31 in annual passive income on a $3,000 investment, a blended yield of 7.31%. Ares Capital contributes $99.02, EPR Properties adds $63.86, and Main Street Capital rounds out the group with $56.43.
The practical value of a portfolio like this is optionality. Dividends land in cash, and the reinvestment decision belongs to the shareholder every payment: buy more of the same name, rotate into a cheaper yield, or take the cash out. That flexibility is difficult to replicate in a rental property or a private credit fund with quarterly gates, and it compounds meaningfully when reinvested at ultra-high yields over multi-year holding periods.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Joel South covers large-cap stocks, dividend investing, and major market trends, with a focus on earnings analysis, valuation, and turning complex data into actionable insights for investors.
He brings more than 15 years of experience as an investor and financial journalist, including 12 years at The Motley Fool, where he served as an investment analyst, Bureau Chief, and later led the Fool.com investing news desk. He has also co-hosted an investing podcast and appeared across TV and radio discussing market trends.
