NEWS
/
MSU
MSU students, professors consider alternatives as AI-usage accusations grow
As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly integrated into higher education, Michigan State University students are raising concerns about being falsely accused of using AI, prompting questions about detection tools, academic integrity and the future of college assignments.
For students who spend hours researching, writing and revising assignments, the possibility that their work could be flagged as AI-generated raises concerns about the reliability of the technology used to enforce academic integrity policies.
Economics freshman Poe Meh said seeing students share experiences of being falsely accused of using AI on social media has made her apprehensive about submitting assignments.
“It’s something that I’m scared of because I’ve seen how some students get accused of using AI when they didn’t,” Meh said. “So when you put in all of that hard work and then get accused of something like that, it doesn’t make you feel good.”
Daniel Kramer, a professor at Michigan State University’s James Madison College, said his approach to AI is still developing alongside the technology. In his courses, Kramer permits certain uses, including editing, spell-checking and refining writing, while generally prohibiting AI-generated first and final drafts.
Although Kramer has used AI detection tools, he said he does not consider them reliable enough to establish whether a student has used AI.
“I don’t believe they’re reliable enough to say that you necessarily used AI, or you didn’t use AI,” Kramer said.
Instead, Kramer said he uses detection results to initiate conversations with students about their writing rather than treating them as definitive evidence of academic misconduct.
International relations junior Matthew Horne also questioned the reliability of AI detection tools and their potential consequences for students.
“You’re relying on AI to tell you that I used AI when I actually didn’t use AI,” Horne said.
Horne said he uses AI to generate ideas and help him begin assignments, but believes students should remain responsible for their work.
“It’s what your brain is supposed to be used for, not the computer,” Horne said.
For some students and professors, addressing concerns about false accusations may require reconsidering how universities evaluate academic work.
Kramer said James Madison College’s emphasis on critical thinking, written communication and engagement with multiple sources creates an environment where students must demonstrate a deeper understanding of their assignments. The college’s use of in-person blue book examinations and extensive writing assignments can also make it more difficult for students to rely entirely on AI-generated work.
